Why the Nancy Guthrie Kidnap Theory Doesn't Add Up and Her Family Should Prep for the Worst #shorts

Veteran homicide investigator Paul Ciolino, who has worked with 48 Hours and CBS News as an on-air expert, says key elements of a true kidnapping aren’t pres...

Why the Nancy Guthrie Kidnap Theory Doesn't Add Up and Her Family Should Prep for the Worst #shorts
New York Post
148.5K views • Feb 10, 2026
Why the Nancy Guthrie Kidnap Theory Doesn't Add Up and Her Family Should Prep for the Worst #shorts

About this video

Veteran homicide investigator Paul Ciolino, who has worked with 48 Hours and CBS News as an on-air expert, says key elements of a true kidnapping aren’t present in the Nancy Guthrie case. With more than 25 years appearing on hundreds of programs across major U.S. and Canadian networks, Ciolino points to the lack of negotiations, forensic evidence, and planning signs as major red flags.

#nancyguthrie #PaulCiollino

The New York Post is your source for breaking news, news about New York, sports, business, entertainment, opinion, real estate, culture, fashion, and more.

Check out our three new podcasts:
NYNext (week): https://www.youtube.com/@nynext1
Pod Force One with MIranda Devine (weekly): https://www.youtube.com/@PodForce1
NY POSTcast (daily): https://www.youtube.com/@NYPOSTcast

Get The Post’s latest headlines everyday with our Morning Report newsletter:
https://tinyurl.com/NYPOSTSIGNUP

Catch the latest news at http://www.nypost.com.
Follow The New York Post on:
Twitter - https://twitter.com/nypost
Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/NYPost

Tags and Topics

Browse our collection to discover more content in these categories.

Video Information

Views

148.5K

Likes

3.1K

Duration

1:43

Published

Feb 10, 2026

User Reviews

4.7
(29)
Rate:

Related Trending Topics

LIVE TRENDS

Related trending topics. Click any trend to explore more videos.

No specific trending topics match this video yet.

Explore All Trends